Yes, both hosts have the same info for subnet mask, gw, and the correct IP's.
However, the vmkernel adapters are marked differently and I'm not sure how this would impact - for example, the original host's mgmt vmk0 is labeled incorrectly but with the correct IP address and on a dvswitch. The second host has a mgmt vmk0 on a switch -
I'm not sure how (if any) much impact vmk's would have on this quite honestly. Otherwise, I may reach out to VMware tech support.