Hi,
Welcome to VMTN. 🙂
VMFS3 and VMFS5 are compatible with ESXi 5.1. Choose VMFS5 if you have to. Refer to below VMware KB on same.
Frequently Asked Questions on VMware vSphere 5.x for VMFS-5 (2003813)
Consider marking this response as "Correct" or "Helpful" if you think my response helped you in any way.