VMware Cloud Community
MABEs
Contributor
Contributor
Jump to solution

Mixing different size Disk groups on same host

Hi,

we currently have 4 nodes with a 800gb cache and two 1.92TB capacity disks, If I want to add a second Disk group to the host, can it consist of a 800 gb cache and two 3.84 TB disks?

i.e on each host:

DG1: 1 x 800 GB Cache and 2 x 1.92TB Capacity

DG2: 1 x 800 GB Cache and 2 x 3.84TB Capacity

Pros and cons of a setup like this?

Thanks!

0 Kudos
1 Solution

Accepted Solutions
TheBobkin
Champion
Champion
Jump to solution

Hello MABEs

"If I want to add a second Disk group to the host, can it consist of a 800 gb cache and two 3.84 TB disks?"

Yes this is supported but may have performance implications.

Assuming you have the same % used on both/all Disk-Groups, the larger ones will invariably be relatively busier as they are serving more data, as a result they will be under more pressure (especially considering you halved the cache:capacity ratio) - this means these will not operate as fast as the smaller disk-group and accordingly the speed of the smaller disk-groups may be affected (as these will end up 'waiting' for the larger, slower Disk-Group).

Please do consider that you are sizing your cache:capacity ratio appropriately for the design type, cluster configuration and workload requirements:

Hybrid:

https://blogs.vmware.com/virtualblocks/2017/01/18/designing-vsan-disk-groups-cache-ratio-revisited/

All-Flash:

http://www.yellow-bricks.com/2016/02/16/10-rule-vsan-caching-calculate-vm-basis-not-disk-capacity/

General guidelines on sizing:

https://storagehub.vmware.com/t/vmware-vsan/vmware-r-vsan-tm-design-and-sizing-guide/

A potential way of using larger drives but not impacting overall performance so much would be to use half as many double-sized capacity-tier drives per Disk-Group so as to retain the same cache:capacity ratio (and add more Disk-Groups if necessary) - note that simply adding larger cache devices (e.g. 2TB) won't really benefit here as vSAN is realistically only going to utilise 600GB cache per Disk-Group.

Bob

View solution in original post

0 Kudos
1 Reply
TheBobkin
Champion
Champion
Jump to solution

Hello MABEs

"If I want to add a second Disk group to the host, can it consist of a 800 gb cache and two 3.84 TB disks?"

Yes this is supported but may have performance implications.

Assuming you have the same % used on both/all Disk-Groups, the larger ones will invariably be relatively busier as they are serving more data, as a result they will be under more pressure (especially considering you halved the cache:capacity ratio) - this means these will not operate as fast as the smaller disk-group and accordingly the speed of the smaller disk-groups may be affected (as these will end up 'waiting' for the larger, slower Disk-Group).

Please do consider that you are sizing your cache:capacity ratio appropriately for the design type, cluster configuration and workload requirements:

Hybrid:

https://blogs.vmware.com/virtualblocks/2017/01/18/designing-vsan-disk-groups-cache-ratio-revisited/

All-Flash:

http://www.yellow-bricks.com/2016/02/16/10-rule-vsan-caching-calculate-vm-basis-not-disk-capacity/

General guidelines on sizing:

https://storagehub.vmware.com/t/vmware-vsan/vmware-r-vsan-tm-design-and-sizing-guide/

A potential way of using larger drives but not impacting overall performance so much would be to use half as many double-sized capacity-tier drives per Disk-Group so as to retain the same cache:capacity ratio (and add more Disk-Groups if necessary) - note that simply adding larger cache devices (e.g. 2TB) won't really benefit here as vSAN is realistically only going to utilise 600GB cache per Disk-Group.

Bob

0 Kudos